What the AI Will Never Understand - Essay by Greg Luti
Updated: 6 days ago

An essay about the limits of a tool. In “What the AI Will Never Understand,” Greg Luti looks at what AI can do with tasks and what it still cannot do with human experience, history, or real creative judgment.
AI in the Conversation
We live in the age of AI, and that is scary to some and intriguing to others. It seems as though you can’t get very far into a conversation without the intention of the new technology being brought up.
What is so interesting about AI is how it has slipped into general public discourse in a time when the media is fractured, and the biggest movies and songs are not known by everyone. Ask someone about technology, and it won’t be long until they give you their thoughts on the new feature.
What AI Can’t Do as a Creator
Now, I will tell you how I feel about AI as a man who creates stories. AI can’t actually create anything from scratch. It needs me to give it input.
Sometimes I like to give AI my stories to see what it has to say about them, and the theme is always the same. The AI doesn’t know what it is like to be human. It will tell me things that I already know, and sometimes I admit, the refresher is quite helpful.
The Poem and the Opening
I will give you an example: I wrote up a poem called The Toll and wanted to see what the AI felt about it. The introduction didn’t work for the computer. It didn’t like it, and it didn’t get to the point right away. I vetoed the idea and said that the beginning stays, because it was well written and brought up a good idea I felt was worth saying.
The AI always wants me to get right into the action of the piece, rather than spending time introducing the actual story. I get the criticism, but when the words of a piece are properly written, then the introduction can be a bit long, since the quality is already there.
The part where I stopped looking for deeper analysis from the AI for my stories was when I noticed it wanted me to explain why I wrote the words. It felt like an interrogation more than simple feedback.
“You should explain this part a bit better.”
“This part was unclear.”
I corrected the AI the first time, and then after I noticed the pattern, I made a request… Give me general feedback on the piece. Do not…. And I mean, do not rewrite it for me. You are not in my head, and I don’t have to explain every word I write for you so that you can understand.
I kid you not, I gave my resume to AI to get some tips on how to improve, and the AI said my resume was only okay. There was nothing really all that special about it. I was a little frustrated. I pointed out my expertise in three different fields, and even then the AI was not all that kind.
Useful for Admin, Useless for Creativity
And that is the lesson I kept learning from AI. It can help me with remembering things I don’t want to bother with, like my schedule or other administrative stuff, but as far as creativity, it is practically useless.
The AI doesn’t understand why the impossible tasks are even attempted. It can tell you the answer that your teacher tells you in school, but that is about it. See, we all know the teacher in school tells you the answer, goes on a diatribe about his summer trip, brings up last night’s sports game, and then briefly mentions how there is more to that answer than just the answer.
There are two examples I think of when it comes to AI and how it really is only helpful for certain things.
Alexander the Great
The first is the Macedonian leader Alexander the Great. AI won’t know why he did what he did, conquering the ancient world. It won’t know what would possess a man to be that ambitious in his own life. And why does the AI not get the man’s intentions? Because we don’t really understand him. What Alexander the Great did was crazy then, and it is crazy now, and yet he did it. That contradiction makes no sense to the AI. And yet every generation that is introduced to the man takes away something different, and for the reason that we all understand that being a human is complicated. He is not defined by one answer. Part of why we don’t know is also why we do know.
Even some of his actions, like how he was basically always outnumbered, would be foolish to the AI. We view it as part of his military genius. To go back to the classroom, the AI would tell you the correct answer about Alexander the Great and then move on. The technical answer that you should remember for the test. Because it doesn’t get why he would make so many reckless decisions and still continue to win, and not only win, but continue to want to even fight. What drives a man to do that? The AI can give you the answer, but it can never live the life of an actual man.
The Greatest Band
Then there is the second example I think about when it comes to computers.
Who is the greatest band of all time? Do you have a choice? If you are like many, you probably have a certain band that popped into your head, one you feel is the best. Society has deemed that there is a certain group of Englishmen that are, in fact, the best band ever, and we call them the Beatles.
There are arguments on both sides, of course. Those who think the Beatles are not only the best, but will then go out of their way to prove it, through song demos, stories, and other personal anecdotes. They will be upset at you if you claim another band is better than the Beatles.
Then there is the other side, who argue that the Beatles are not the best band ever. They name their own band and cite reasons why that is the case. Perhaps they name the band for their proficiency in a certain style, or their longevity, or because of another accomplishment the band has that the advocate feels puts them as the top band.
Both care a lot about their arguments. People are not just defending a group of musicians but a culture, a movement, and a level of expertise in the field. They want their band to be the best. If the Beatles are the best, that means something for music. If another band is the best, that means something else for music.
If you ask AI who the greatest band is of all time, the AI will tell you it is the Beatles and perhaps a few reasons for that being the case. That is it. The AI doesn’t actually care if the Beatles are the best band ever. It has no stake in the question. You simply asked it a question, and it gave you the answer.
That is wild to me, because the passion from music lovers is really the heart of the question, not the answer itself. You know how they say that it is the journey, not the destination, that matters. That is what we are talking about here.
AI as a Tool
I am not one of those people who is against AI and feels it should be banned. In fact, I abhor those who don’t address the hypocrisy of the use of AI among the youth. They will mock the kids for using AI for their assignments and say the kids should know the stuff, but meanwhile we all use AI to write up our emails and create our newsletters. When a kid uses AI to complete his report, that is bad. But when you use it to email your boss, that is fine. Come on now, we all know the real issue.
We are not treating AI for what it actually is: a tool. And all tools depend on the understanding of the wielder. A hammer in the hand of a man who doesn’t know how to use one is pointless. We should then see that AI is not all bad. If we treat it as such, then the students will just go around us and use it anyway.
When I was a kid, the cheat code in school was Spark Notes. You didn’t really read the entire book, at least I didn’t. I read the Spark Notes and then got the idea of it. That is what kids are doing with AI today.
Know When to Use It
I am sure that AI will continue to be a point of fascination for many, and we should use these discussions to better understand the actual features. Know when to use AI. Know when not to use it. At the end of the day, the machine is only as useful as the inputs it is given, and we are the ones inputting the commands. We should remember that.





Comments